TGIC vs HAA: Which System Is Better for Outdoor Applications?
Outdoor powder coatings must withstand sunlight, UV radiation, temperature changes, moisture, and long-term environmental exposure. For this reason, the choice between TGIC and HAA curing systems is one of the most important formulation decisions for manufacturers. Both systems are commonly used with polyester Resins, but they differ significantly in weathering resistance, mechanical strength, curing behavior, and long-term performance.
Understanding how each curing agent performs outdoors helps formulators select the system that delivers the best durability and appearance stability. With PCOTEC’s curing agent portfolio—TGIC grades TK-902/TK-906 and HAA grades TK-H220/TK-H320—we can compare these systems based on field performance, processing requirements, and application targets.
Table of Contents
Overview of TGIC and HAA Systems
TGIC (Triglycidyl Isocyanurate)
A highly reactive epoxy-functional curing agent widely used in outdoor polyester powder coatings. Known for its exceptional UV stability and strong mechanical properties.
HAA (β-Hydroxyalkylamide)
An eco-friendly, formaldehyde-free curing agent used in indoor and selected outdoor polyester coatings. It offers smooth appearance and good gloss stability but has limitations in harsh weather environments.
Key Differences in Outdoor Performance
1. UV Resistance
TGIC:
Provides superior UV and sunlight resistance due to a stable crosslinked network.HAA:
Moderate UV resistance; may show faster gloss loss under prolonged exposure.
2. Weatherability
TGIC:
Excellent retention of gloss, color, and mechanical strength in outdoor conditions.HAA:
Suitable for indoor and mild outdoor conditions but not ideal for extreme UV zones.
3. Durability
TGIC:
Outstanding long-term durability; resists chalking and fading.HAA:
Good stability but not as strong as TGIC for automotive, architectural, or heavy-duty use.
Performance Comparison Table
| Performance Factor | TGIC System | HAA System |
|---|---|---|
| UV Resistance | Excellent | Moderate |
| Outdoor Weatherability | Very Strong | Good to Moderate |
| Gloss Retention | High | Moderate |
| Chemical Resistance | High | Medium |
| Film Hardness | Strong | Medium |
| Heat Stability | Very Good | Good |
| Environmental Profile | Conventional | Eco-friendly |
| Typical Curing | 180–200°C | 160–190°C |
TGIC clearly offers superior outdoor durability, while HAA provides environmental benefits and smoother appearance but with limitations in aggressive climates.
Why TGIC Performs Better Outdoors
Several structural and chemical factors explain TGIC’s stronger outdoor performance:
1. Dense Crosslinking Structure
TGIC forms a tightly crosslinked polyester network that resists UV-induced degradation.
2. Higher Resistance to Hydrolysis
Moisture and humidity have less impact on TGIC-cured films, reducing chalking and blistering.
3. Strong Mechanical Properties
The cured film retains impact, scratch resistance, and flexibility longer than HAA systems.
4. Better Color and Gloss Stability
Even after years of exposure, TGIC systems maintain visual consistency.
5. Broad Application Range
TGIC handles extreme sunlight, temperature shifts, and environmental stress better than HAA.
When HAA Can Be Used Outdoors
While TGIC is preferred for most outdoor environments, HAA can still be used in certain conditions:
Suitable outdoor scenarios for HAA:
Mild climates with low UV exposure
Shaded or partially indoor environments
Coatings where eco-friendly profile is a priority
Applications requiring smooth, uniform appearance
Projects targeting lower curing temperatures
However, HAA is not recommended for:
High-UV regions (Middle East, Australia, South America)
Automotive exteriors
Architectural aluminum exposed to direct sunlight
Industrial equipment in outdoor service
PCOTEC’s TGIC and HAA Solutions
PCOTEC supplies both curing systems, allowing customers to select the best option based on performance needs.
PCOTEC TGIC Grades
TK-902
High purity, controlled melting range, excellent durability.TK-906
Smooth appearance and stable reaction behavior.
PCOTEC HAA Grades
TK-H220
Balanced flow and cure for smooth finishes.TK-H320
Strong gloss uniformity and consistent curing.
Each grade is tested for:
Melting behavior
Volatile content
Reactivity
Compatibility with PCOTEC Polyester Resins
Ensuring stable performance in industrial production.
How to Choose the Right System for Outdoor Use
Choose TGIC if:
The coating will face direct sunlight
Long-term gloss retention is required
Automotive, architectural, or industrial durability is needed
Maximum UV and chalking resistance is essential
Harsh weather exposure is expected
Choose HAA if:
The application is mainly indoor or semi-outdoor
Eco-friendly formulation is required
Lower curing temperatures are needed
Appearance smoothness is a priority
Cost optimization is important
Real-World Outdoor Application Examples
Best for TGIC Systems:
Building facades
Outdoor machinery
Automotive trim
Guardrails and metal structures
Outdoor furniture
Industrial equipment exposed to weather
Possible for HAA Systems:
Residential appliances
Indoor furniture
Light outdoor use with limited UV
Commercial fixtures under cover
Conclusion
For outdoor applications, TGIC is unquestionably the superior curing system due to its outstanding UV stability, weathering resistance, chemical durability, and long-term gloss retention. It remains the industry standard for architectural, automotive, and heavy-duty industrial coatings.
HAA offers environmental advantages and excellent appearance quality but cannot match TGIC’s performance under intense sunlight or harsh climatic conditions. It is best suited for indoor applications or mild outdoor environments.
PCOTEC provides both TGIC (TK-902 / TK-906) and HAA (TK-H220 / TK-H320) Curing Agents. Our technical team helps customers choose the right system based on climate, performance requirements, and formulation flexibility.
For high-performance outdoor powder coatings, TGIC remains the better choice, delivering reliable durability and long-term protection.
Previous: What Is Titanium Dioxide?
Next: What Is Resin Made Of?